Sola Scriptura, Part Two: The Long Conversation
Three Centuries of Sorting
The scene
Alexandria, Egypt, in the spring of AD 367. As he did every year, Athanasius, the bishop of the city, sends out a letter announcing the date of Easter to the churches of Egypt. This year's letter, his thirty-ninth, contains something new. He lists the books of the New Testament, and there are exactly twenty-seven of them, the same twenty-seven found in Bibles today. It is the earliest surviving list that matches ours exactly. Then he adds a warning: "In these alone is proclaimed the doctrine of godliness. Let no man add to these, neither let him take ought from these."
He also names some books that are good for new believers to read, but that are not part of the list: the Wisdom of Solomon, Sirach, Esther, Judith, Tobit, the Teaching of the Apostles (also called the Didache), and the Shepherd of Hermas.
How did the churches get from a handful of letters read aloud in house churches to a list like this? To see that, the story has to rewind about two hundred years. It starts with a part of the conversation that is easy to forget: the edge of the Old Testament was being debated too. This is the second of three cards. As in the first, "those who hold to that position" means those who hold that the church's teaching office and tradition stand alongside Scripture as an authority, and that the church's decision settles which books belong in the Bible.
1. The Old Testament boundary
Before following the New Testament story, it helps to notice that Athanasius's list of books for new believers included Old Testament books as well. The edge of the Old Testament was also under discussion, and that conversation ran longer than any other.
Melito's list. Around 170, Melito, a bishop of Sardis, went "to the East," to the place where these things were preached and done, and sent his friend Onesimus a list of the Old Testament books. Eusebius preserves it in his Church History (book 4, chapter 26). The list closely matches the Hebrew canon. It has no Wisdom of Solomon, Sirach, Tobit, Judith, or Maccabees. Two details need care. The "Wisdom" in his list is Proverbs, which he calls "Proverbs, also called Wisdom," not the Wisdom of Solomon. And Esther is missing. The list itself is plain in the source. That Melito learned it from Jewish communities is an inference from the words "the East," a reasonable one but held with moderate confidence.
The Greek Bible. Many early Christians read the Old Testament in Greek, in the translation called the Septuagint. The great Christian copies of it carry some of the extra books mixed in among the others, with no separate section, and which ones appear varies from codex to codex. Codex Vaticanus, for example, has no books of Maccabees, while Codex Sinaiticus has 1 and 4 Maccabees. That pattern is clear in the great codices of the fourth and fifth centuries. What the earlier Jewish Greek collection contained before Christian times is much less certain.
Jerome. From the 390s, Jerome translated the Old Testament from the Hebrew. He called the extra books apocrypha and said the church reads them for edification, but not to establish doctrine. Even so, those books ended up in the Vulgate, the Latin Bible that grew out of his work. All of this is well documented.
Augustine and North Africa. Augustine, in On Christian Doctrine (book 2, chapter 8), lists the fuller set as canonical, including Tobit, Judith, Wisdom, Sirach, and two books of Maccabees. So do the councils of Hippo in 393 and Carthage in 397. Hippo's list survives only through the summary that Carthage adopted. This, too, is plain in the sources.
The later split. The question stayed open for more than a thousand years. The Council of Florence listed the same fuller set in 1442, and the Council of Trent defined it as dogma in 1546. At the Reformation, the Reformers went back to Jerome's Hebrew line. Luther's Bible of 1534 printed the extra books in a separate section, as useful to read but not equal to Scripture. These dates and decisions are well established.
How does this serve the larger question? Both sides appeal to what the church received. One side points to Melito and Jerome, and the other to the North African councils. The Old Testament edge stayed debated far longer than the New Testament edge. That seems to sharpen the question this series keeps asking: did the church recognize the canon, or create it? That is an inference, held with moderate confidence, and the history itself does not settle it.
2. A core that was never in doubt
By the middle of the second century, the Gospels were already part of Sunday worship. Around 150 to 155, Justin Martyr described a typical Christian gathering in Rome: "the memoirs of the apostles or the writings of the prophets are read, as long as time permits." He explains elsewhere that these memoirs "are called Gospels."
Around 180, Irenaeus, a bishop in Gaul, could write that "It is not possible that the Gospels can be either more or fewer in number than they are." By then the four Gospels, Acts, and the letters of Paul were being read across the churches.
There were pressures pushing in other directions. Around 140, a teacher in Rome named Marcion used a shortened version of Luke and a cut-down set of Paul's letters. Irenaeus says Marcion "mutilates the Gospel which is according to Luke." Some historians think Marcion pushed the churches to say more clearly which books they used. That is likely part of the story, but it was one pressure among several, and how large a role it played is debated.
The sources show plainly that this core was in wide use well before any list was drawn up.
3. Lists that show the debate
The early lists are valuable because they show the churches thinking out loud.
The Muratorian Fragment is a Latin list found in a library in Milan and first published in 1740. The copy we have was made in the seventh or eighth century, and its beginning and end are missing. It names Luke as the third Gospel and John as the fourth, so Matthew and Mark were probably named in the lost opening. It includes Acts, thirteen letters of Paul, Jude, two letters of John, the Wisdom of Solomon, and two books of revelation, John's and one attributed to Peter, adding that "some of us are not willing that the latter be read in church." It leaves out Hebrews, James, and both letters of Peter. Most scholars date the list to the late second century, but some serious scholars argue it comes from the fourth, and that question is not settled.
In the third century, Origen of Alexandria was reported to call the four Gospels "the only indisputable ones in the Church of God under heaven." He was less sure of others. Peter, he says, left one letter that everyone accepts, "perhaps also a second, but this is doubtful." About Hebrews he wrote, "But who wrote the epistle, in truth, God knows."
Around 325, the historian Eusebius sorted the books into groups in his Church History (book 3, chapter 25): those accepted everywhere, those disputed but known to many, and those rejected. James, Jude, 2 Peter, and 2 and 3 John are in the disputed group. Revelation is strange: he places it among the accepted books and also among the rejected ones, each time with the phrase "if it seem proper." Hebrews is not named in that chapter at all.
Those details come straight from the sources. The early date of the Muratorian list is the part that should be held more loosely.
4. The edges
So which books were still being talked about? Mainly Hebrews, James, 2 Peter, 2 and 3 John, Jude, and Revelation. Some other writings sat just outside the edge. Athanasius recommended the Didache and the Shepherd of Hermas for new believers but did not count them in the list. One large Bible copied in the fourth century, Codex Sinaiticus, includes the Letter of Barnabas and part of the Shepherd.
There is a quiet irony here. One of the books still debated, Jude, speaks of the faith as something already handed over and complete.
Jude 3 (ESV): "Beloved, although I was very eager to write to you about our common salvation, I found it necessary to write appealing to you to contend for the faith that was once for all delivered to the saints."
The churches were still sorting the edges of the list, while the faith itself was already understood as something given, not invented.
5. The councils speak of receiving
The first church councils to publish a list of books met in North Africa. The list of the council of Hippo in 393 survives only through the summary that Carthage adopted in 397. That summary says nothing should be read in church "under the name of divine Scriptures" except the canonical books. It then lists them, including our twenty-seven New Testament books, and asks that "the church across the sea" be consulted to confirm the list. The report behind this series checked that wording only through secondary sources, so it counts as partly verified.
The council of Carthage in 419 repeated the list. Its canon ends this way: "Let this be sent to our brother and fellow bishop, Boniface, and to the other bishops of those parts, that they may confirm this canon, for these are the things which we have received from our fathers to be read in church." That wording is verified in the standard English translation of the council's canons.
One correction is worth making here. The clearest "received from our fathers" wording belongs to the council of 419. The report does not show that same phrase in the summary from 393 and 397. So the argument below leans on the 419 council's words, and it should be stated with a little more care than if every council had said the same thing.
These were regional councils, not councils of the whole church. They asked bishops overseas to confirm what they had done. That the councils were confirming books already in use is strongly suggested for the core books. For the edges, the councils' judgment did more real work.
6. No council did it first
No council of the whole church issued a list of books in this period. The surviving canons of the Council of Nicaea in 325 contain no list. The only ancient hint otherwise comes from Jerome, who says in his preface to Judith that the council "is read" to have counted Judith among the Scriptures. That is a report of a report, with no surviving decree behind it.
As the first section showed, the Old Testament edges were not settled either. Jerome placed books like Judith and Tobit outside the canon, while the African councils and Augustine included them. The early church did not speak with one voice there.
The thread: guarded, not created?
If the councils mostly confirmed books that churches had been reading for generations, and the gospel had been making believers the whole time, what does that suggest? Did the church give these books their authority, or did it recognize an authority they already had?
There is a useful distinction here. The church clearly guarded the message. It sorted, copied, defended, and listed these writings. Nothing in the sources shows a council claiming to have created them. The 419 council's own word, "received," points in that direction. That the church guarded these books is plain from what it did. That it did not see itself as creating them is a reasonable reading of the councils' language, though it rests mainly on one council's wording.
The strongest objection
The edges took more than three centuries to settle, so the church's judgment clearly did real work. Those who hold to that position say that a guardian able to settle the list reliably must itself have authority. That is a serious objection, and this card does not claim to have answered it. It can only pose a question back: is guarding something entrusted to you the same as having authority over it?
Two more points of honesty. Going from "the church recognized these books" to "these books are infallible, and they are the only infallible rule" is an inference. The history supports it, but it does not state it. And the phrase "Scripture alone" comes from the Reformation era, more than a thousand years later. The question is whether the conviction behind it is older.
Timeline: writers and councils, c. 96 to 419
Each entry gives a date, a source, what it shows, and how it was checked in the report behind this series. "Verified" means the source text was checked in a standard translation. "Partly verified" means it was checked only through secondary sources, summaries, or catalogue records.
- c. 96: 1 Clement 47. The church in Rome tells the Corinthians to "take up the epistle of the blessed Apostle Paul." Verified.
- c. 107 to 110: Ignatius of Antioch, Ephesians 12.2. Speaks of Paul, "who in all his Epistles makes mention of you." Verified. A minority of scholars date Ignatius to the 140s.
- c. 110 to 140: Polycarp, Philippians 12.1. Calls a line found only in Ephesians 4:26 part of "these Scriptures." Verified from the Latin text.
- c. 110 to 130: Papias, reported by Eusebius. Says Mark wrote down Peter's preaching and that Matthew wrote the Lord's sayings. Verified.
- c. 130: Letter of Barnabas 4.14. Introduces "Many are called, but few are chosen" with "as it is written." Verified.
- c. 120 to 150: 2 Clement 2.4. Calls a saying of Jesus "another Scripture." Text verified; date not checked.
- c. 140: Marcion in Rome. Uses a shortened Luke and a set of Paul's letters. Partly verified.
- c. 150 to 155: Justin Martyr. The "memoirs of the apostles" are read with the prophets on Sunday. Verified.
- c. 170: Melito of Sardis, reported by Eusebius. Lists the Old Testament books he learned in the East; the list closely matches the Hebrew canon, calls Proverbs also Wisdom, and leaves out Esther. Verified.
- c. 180: Irenaeus, Against Heresies 3.11.8. Four Gospels, no more and no fewer. Verified.
- Late second century, or possibly fourth: Muratorian Fragment. Leaves out Hebrews, James, and 1 and 2 Peter. Contents verified; date debated; manuscript date partly verified.
- Third century: Origen, reported by Eusebius. Four Gospels undisputed; 2 Peter doubtful; Hebrews' author known to God. Verified.
- 325: Council of Nicaea. No list of books in its surviving canons; Jerome's later remark about Judith is hearsay. Partly verified.
- c. 325: Eusebius, Church History 3.25. Accepted, disputed, and rejected books. Verified.
- 367: Athanasius, Festal Letter 39. The earliest surviving list of exactly our twenty-seven books. Verified.
- c. 391: Jerome, preface to the books of Samuel and Kings. Places Wisdom, Sirach, Judith, Tobit, and the Shepherd outside the canon. Verified.
- 393: Council of Hippo. Its list survives only through the summary Carthage adopted in 397. Partly verified.
- 397: Council of Carthage. Adopts the Hippo summary and asks the church across the sea to confirm it. Partly verified.
- 419: Council of Carthage, canon 24. Repeats the list: "these are the things which we have received from our fathers to be read in church." Verified.
Closing question
If the core was settled by use and the edges by long debate, what does it mean that the church spoke of receiving these books, and of guarding them, rather than choosing them?